Close Menu
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Vimeo
    Subscribe Login
    • Home
    • Boston Sports
    • LOCAL BOSTON SPORTS NEWS
    • Massachusetts
    • New England Sports
    • Home
    • About Us
    • Contact
    • Privacy & policy
    Home»Boston Sports»Dustin Pedroia, Jon Lester make Hall of Fame ballot – will the Red Sox ever retire their numbers?
    Boston Sports

    Dustin Pedroia, Jon Lester make Hall of Fame ballot – will the Red Sox ever retire their numbers?

    BostonSportsNewsBy BostonSportsNewsNovember 17, 2026No Comments7 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr WhatsApp VKontakte Email
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email


    Who is going to be the next Red Sox player to have his number retired? The fact that there isn’t an obvious answer is indicative of the superstar churn the Red Sox have gone through recently.

    For a while, the Sox had three steadfast rules for putting a number up on the facade: the player had to spend at least 10 years with the Red Sox, finish his career with the Red Sox, and be elected to the Hall of Fame. If those rules weren’t quite written in stone, then they were at least chiseled in Fenway brick, and entire generations of fans could name the only four players who met the criteria: Ted Williams, Carl Yastrzemski, Bobby Doerr, and Joe Cronin.

    But after a clumsy attempt at having Carlton Fisk “retire” with the team 20 years after he last played for it, the Sox finally threw that criteria in the trash. The realities of modern player movement meant that the Sox couldn’t afford to be so selective anymore. Of the six players who have had their numbers retired since the first four, only David Ortiz and Jim Rice would’ve met the original criteria.

    I generally admired the Sox’ prior restraint when it came to hanging up the digits. But I also wouldn’t want to live in a world in which Pedro Martinez’s #45 was being worn by some middle reliever the team picked up off the waiver wire. So I’m willing to be flexible and accept that there are no rules anymore, and that every player is going to be considered on a case-by-case basis.

    But even considering the new anarchic world we find ourselves in with respect to retired numbers, the Red Sox are in an interesting spot. Because, shockingly, there really aren’t any obvious candidates for who will be the next player to watch his number go up on the right field facade.

    BOSTON, MA - JULY 28: David Ortiz #34 of the Boston Red Sox hugs Pedro Martinez, a former member of the Boston Red Sox, during a ceremony to retire Martinez’s number 45 before a game with the Chicago White Sox at Fenway Park on July 28, 2015 in Boston, Massachusetts. (Photo by Jim Rogash/Getty Images)

    BOSTON, MA – JULY 28: David Ortiz #34 of the Boston Red Sox hugs Pedro Martinez, a former member of the Boston Red Sox, during a ceremony to retire Martinez’s number 45 before a game with the Chicago White Sox at Fenway Park on July 28, 2015 in Boston, Massachusetts. (Photo by Jim Rogash/Getty Images)
    Getty Images

    When considering possible candidates, we first have to acknowledge that, even though the sox technically got rid of the Hall of Fame requirement… they really didn’t. Johnny Pesky is the only player they’ve honored with a retired number who isn’t in the HOF, and he was clearly being honored in a lifetime achievement sort of way. Manny Ramirez, Dwight Evans, and Roger Clemens are all still on the outside looking in, and it seems clear that it’s the lack of a plaque in Cooperstown that’s keeping them there (though in Clemens’ case, there’s also the fact that his noxious personality has alienated him from many if not most Sox fans).

    So what recent Red Sox players could even make it to Cooperstown in the foreseeable future? There are two easy ones. Mookie Betts will sail in on the first ballot and be remembered as one of the top-5 players of his generation. He’s currently second amongst active players in bWAR, trailing only Mike Trout. And then there’s Chris Sale who, with the retirement of Justin Verlander and the inevitable-but-not-yet-official retirement of Max Scherzer, will be the active leader in pitching bWAR when baseball resumes in 2027.

    But let’s face it: neither Betts nor Sale will ever go up on the facade. Betts has already spent more time in LA than Boston and, through no fault of his own, has come represent the post-2018 quagmire the Sox are still trying to dig themselves out of. Chris Sale’s Red Sox tenure will be remembered more for his injuries than for anything he did on the mound, despite the handful of great years he had here.

    Other fan favorites like Xander Bogaerts, Kevin Youkilis, and Nomar Garciaparra didn’t quite have Cooperstown-worthy careers. Manny Ramirez obviously did, but is being kept out for his failed steroid tests. Dwight Evans is in some ways the personification of the modern Cooperstown bubble case. And while his career is constantly being debated and reassessed, he fell off the ballot long ago and now has to rely on the arcane committee process.

    No one on the current roster has a credible case for Cooperstown yet. Aroldis Chapman comes closest, but I don’t think it’s a given that he gets in in light of his volatile career and off-field issues (and he won’t be here long enough to reach retired number status anyway). And while it’s not hard to imagine that Garrett Crochet and Roman Anthony could be HOF-worthy one day, how confident are you that their Red Sox tenures won’t end acrimoniously, given the recent experiences with Mookie, Xander, Rafael Devers, etc.?

    That really only leaves two candidates: Dustin Pedroia and Jon Lester.

    The 2027 Hall of Fame ballot was announced yesterday and those two prominent ex-Red Sox are on it. Jon Lester is making his first appearance. He has an interesting case, but I think he’ll ultimately fall short. 200 career wins sounds great and he had his October moments, too. But Lester was never considered a Capital-A ACE of the game the way that Verlander, Scherzer, and Sale were. He only finished in the top-5 in his league in ERA four times. And his 43.5 career bWAR puts him league with guys like Al Leiter, Cliff Lee, Jack Morris, and Javier Vazquez.

    I’m confident that Lester will hang on the ballot for 10 years, and arguments in favor of his candidacy will likely gain traction. This is true for no other reason than the fact that he’s a starting pitcher and there’s a simmering dialogue about the need to rethink the way we evaluate the HOF-worthiness of starting pitchers in light of the myriad ways that starting pitching has changed in recent decades. But even though he’ll likely be a prominent subject in that evolving discussion, he’ll find himself justifiably behind guys like Felix Hernandez, Cole Hamels, and Zack Grienke.

    So what about Pedroia? He received over 20% of the vote last year, his second year on the ballot. But while his peak was HOF-worthy, his career was likely just too damn short to merit induction. And, unlike Lester, there isn’t going to be a discussion about the need to rethink the way we evaluate second basemen any time soon. His career bWAR is similar to that of Lance Berkman, Luis Gonzalez, and Torii Hunter (though, for what it’s worth, it is above Bobby Doerr’s). I can see him gaining votes every year, but I don’t think he’ll get to 75%.

    But here’s where I’ll make another prediction: Dustin Pedroia will one day have his #15 retired by the Red Sox. In light of the reason why his career was cut short, he’ll be a sympathetic case, even if he never makes it to Cooperstown. He’s also 10th on the all-time Red Sox WAR leaderboard, ahead not just of Doerr, but Rice and Fisk, too.

    But more importantly, it’s now been 10 years since the Sox last retired a number (David Ortiz’s #34). If Pedroia and Lester don’t make the cut, then, as strange as it sounds to say, we probably would be looking at Anthony and Crochet as the next most likely candidates. That would mean that the Sox could go as much as 30 years or more between retired number ceremonies — and that’s only if Crochet and Anthony ever get there, which should still be considered unlikely at this point. Given the way this ownership group likes to throw a party, I just can’t see that happening.



    Source link

    ballot Dustin Fame Hall Jon Lester numbers Pedroia Red retire Sox
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr WhatsApp Email
    Previous ArticleNBA Picks Today 11/17/2026 | NBA Best Bets, Predictions, and Player Props Tuesday November 17 2026 – Guy Boston Sports
    BostonSportsNews

    Related Posts

    NBA Picks Today 11/17/2026 | NBA Best Bets, Predictions, and Player Props Tuesday November 17 2026 – Guy Boston Sports

    November 17, 2026

    What Red Sox signing Jake Bauers means for Willson Contreras – NBC Boston

    November 17, 2026

    The Moments that Made the 2026 Red Sox: The Sox get knocked down but they get up again, again, again, again, and again

    November 17, 2026

    College Basketball Picks Today Monday 11/16/2026

    November 16, 2026
    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Recent Posts

    • Dustin Pedroia, Jon Lester make Hall of Fame ballot – will the Red Sox ever retire their numbers?
    • NBA Picks Today 11/17/2026 | NBA Best Bets, Predictions, and Player Props Tuesday November 17 2026 – Guy Boston Sports
    • Patriots’ Drake Maye will be sidelined indefinitely with an ankle injury, AP source says – Boston News, Weather, Sports
    • What Red Sox signing Jake Bauers means for Willson Contreras – NBC Boston
    • Bane scores 24, Magic rally in 4th quarter to beat Celtics 115-105, extend win streak to 4 games – Boston News, Weather, Sports

    Recent Comments

    No comments to show.
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest
    • Home
    • About Us
    • Contact
    • Privacy & policy
    © 2026 ThemeSphere. Designed by ThemeSphere.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    Sign In or Register

    Welcome Back!

    Login to your account below.

    Lost password?