The Boston Red Sox are stuck. If you’re the type of person who is content finishing third within the division and being bounced by your arch rivals in just a handful of games in back-to-back seasons, you might disagree. If you’re not an idiot, you know difficult decisions need to be made and that things need to change.
I’ve decided to task myself with analyzing which players can be part of the turnaround and which should be shown the door, all as a way to take the heat off chief baseball officer Craig Breslow. If you’re not down with that, I’ve got two words for ya: Problem or Solution?
The Red Sox are trying to stuff ten pounds of shit decent depth into a five pound bag…
I don’t mean to make it sound so simple, but how else do you describe a situation where there are five players for three spots?
Jake Bauers and Willson Contreras are locked in as the primary first baseman/designated hitter combination heading into 2027, and while the former can technically play some outfield and the latter has some experience behind the dish, those are the only two spots in which we’ll see them moving forward. Curtis Mead and Kristian Campbell can technically put on gloves and stand behind the pitcher, but the prevailing thought is that you can’t allow both of them to play defense — with the former being the obvious leader in the clubhouse to play second base while the latter will continue to develop as a depth piece. Triston Casas is… also there.
Bauers (140 OPS+), Contreras (153 OPS+), and Mead (132 OPS+) are lineup locks after they crushed the baseball last season, which leaves our other two guys fighting for bench roles.
Campbell has positional versatility, in theory, so there could be some sort of role.
Casas hasn’t played baseball in 568 days, has appeared in a total of 82 games in the last two seasons, has seen his OPS+ decrease across his last three seasons (129 in 2023, 124 in 2024, 62 in 2025), is a replacement-level player in all but one of his seasons, and can do exactly two things that are already going to be done by others.
WHAT WE KNOW
Boston’s big plan is to send the guy to try and play baseball for the Tigres del Licey of the Dominican Winter League.
Casas’ injury woes have been the primary reason why people are ready to give up on him. I’d list them out for you but… ah screw it — shoulder inflammation in 2023, rib fracture/torn cartilage/strain/who the hell knows in 2024, ruptured patellar tendon in 2025, and wrist surgery and an abdominal/intercostal strain in 2026.
It’s not just the fact that he’s the glass bones and paper skin from SpongeBob SquarePants, either…
Casas has regressed at the plate — the dry swings when he’s injured haven’t done much to help when he’s not injured — while failing to improve defensively and squarely being their third best option at first base on the roster.
WHAT WE DON’T KNOW
If the injuries are going to continue or if he’s finally going to turn things around.
I can’t say much more than that…
Casas is undoubtedly a hige talent, he just can’t stay on the field and has sort of alienated the entire organization and much of the fan base by being something of a weirdo. I’ve seen plenty of players grow into themselves and turn their careers around — J.D. Martinez sucked for four years before he started consistently getting MVP votes and David Ortiz was notoriously mid during the early portion of his career — but those are extreme examples. It’s a 50/50 toss up on if he’ll ever hit the weight room to even give himself a shot.
The Red Sox have already committed to Bauers.
I’d imagine they’re comfortable moving forward with him as the primary first baseman, but Contreras only has one year left on his deal and Casas is still under team control for three seasons. If you can find a way to keep the latter healthy for Triple-A Worcester, you can either decide to trade him after he recoups some value or you can hold on and try to build him into the player you thought he could be without all the pressure.
WORST-CASE SCENARIO
Bauers or Contreras finds themselves on the injured list, Casas is forced into the lineup but also gets injured, you don’t have anyone to play first base and need to scramble with one of your utility infielders — a.k.a. Romy Gonzalez.
CONCLUSION
I’d be willing to bet that he gets traded next offseason — either following a fully healthy campaign in the minor leagues or following another disastrous injury.